Thursday, December 10, 2020

Meaningless Friendships & Hobbies

 "If we continue to nourish the demons, when will we slay them? If we let our mind dwell on actions and thoughts related to meaningless friendships and habits, when will we mortify the will of the flesh? When will we live the Christ-like life to which we have committed ourselves?"

Theoleptos, Metropolitan of Philadelphia, in The Philokalia, Vol. IV

This text is originally intended for monastics, like the whole of the Philokalia, but we are all entitled to the knowledge and the advice. Obviously, we are not as advanced as these men, and it shocks us to hear about thinking of any friendship or habit as meaningless... 

But, for a minute, we can understand Christ is absolutely everything, and if we do well our fate will be to spend eternity with God and His Angels and Saints, achieving a state of theosis... 

Now, we must see our own friendships with people in this context, and understand that part of our mission in the world ought to be influential in showing people the positivity of God. So, can friendships that result in an explicitly bad or compromising influence on us be good? Of course not. 

Let us also understand that the monks reading this would be in a situation where they are almost exclusively meeting other monks. It is easier for them to give up a friendship at the drop of a hat because they are dealing with other people who are working out their salvation with Christ. 

So, I think it is unnecessary for us to be overly picky in our friendships, but we should be discerning. 

As far as habits go, we should truly reflect on what we are doing. Is it meaningless? Well, we should consider our level of attachment to it, and whether or not it is proving to benefit ourselves and our overall life goal of being a positive influence for Christ. 

It immediately makes me think of my own hobbies... Yes, definitely some of my hobbies seem like a waste of time in the sense that they are just meaningless exercises. I should definitely consider reforming them. But it is also the case that my hobbies can make me closer to other people or provide a very useful way to free my mind and relax. 

In our context, a meaningless hobby would be one that cannot add utility to ourselves or others. In this context, since you are likely more effective & better at socializing and being with others when you are well rested and in a relaxed state, it makes sense to have a nice hobby, does it not? Even if it is one that seems like a time waster to others, it is good if it is calming for yourself. But, if it is not calming, if it is disruptive, it should be cut out. 

Certainly, it is also the case that we ought to choose the more meaningful hobby over the less meaningful whenever that is also possible. 

And, as Met. Theoleptos lastly implies, we need to think about when we will live in a committed way to Christ. Even though we have not reached such a high level of commitment as a monk, we certainly have room to reevaluate our own levels of commitment, and to up our ante. 

Sunday, December 6, 2020

The Unconfused Union of Soul & Body

 St. Niketas Stethatos wrote in the Philokalia, Vol. III:

"The unconfused union and conjunction of soul and body constitutes, when maintained in harmony, a single reality, whether on the visible level or in their inner being. When not harmonious, there is civil war in which each side desires victory. But when the intelligence takes control, it at once puts an end to the jealousy and establishes concord, conforming the entire soul-body reality to its inner being and the Spirit."

Earlier in his treatise on spiritual knowledge, he writes:

"So long as you live according to your fallen impulses you are dominated by your fallen mortal self. But once you die to the world, you are set free from this domination (cf. Rom. 7:2). We cannot die to the world unless we die to the mortal aspects of ourselves."

Which illustrates perfectly how we have to die to our fallen impulses in order to be free. 

Anyone who is thus subject to their base desires cannot be said to be free, for they wage within themselves a civil war between the nous, which pursues righteousness and unity with Heaven, and their base, bodily desires. Of course, the average monk struggles with these issues, let alone the average Christian, but in recognizing this problem and struggling, there can be an actual direction for improvement.

The issue is really the rejection of God -- it will produce the results that we see in Western society today. The body now dictates morality. If a thing can be said to stem from a natural urge, it can be justified in most circumstances. The mind tends to always bend over backwards to justify base desires.

Wednesday, October 28, 2020

Why Monarchy Better Protects Liberty

People tell us democracy is important because liberty is important, but the end product they deliver us is a place like Sweden, France, or the UK, where you can be arrested for thought crime, and places like the USA, where this is the eventual goal that the left is pursuing, and even if they cannot arrest you... they can socially ostracize you & destroy you financially for agitating for a cause that counters their value system.

This is only moderately better than being thrown in Newgate prison for criticizing the mayor in late medieval London. At least when they threw you in Newgate, you were given a chance to fully recant and re-absorbed into society -- if not in London, somewhere else.

I am completely confident that a Monarch will do a better job protecting you from the mob more than the mob itself.

King Charles II of Engalnd, 1630-1685

This is because of the mistake that the democrat makes when they think that it is only the free market where businesses conquer one another & compete, exercising greater amounts of undue power, but this is manageable because it ends up bringing more profit to the people... 

It also occurs in government, and every sort of institution that can then be absorbed by the competing political entities to embellish its power is also absorbed. 

The democratic process itself becomes the enemy of freedom as the possession of mechanisms to disqualify, dominate, and destroy dissidents become weapons in the hands of the competing parties. 

It works just as a monopoly in the marketplace works. It has no mercy or respect for anything but its own power. 

And what makes this far more insidious than any business pursuing unlimited profits, is that it justifies itself in political terms. It casts itself as the hero, and those it vanquishes as villains, and within the political machinery even the cynic that knowingly wields power for the mere sake of power is rare to be seen. They are ideologues enslaved to their own perspective. 

The real ingredients for a free society are the actual constitution of freedom, the various layers of institutional inertia that keep it free, and whatever additional dynamic processes exist that may also thwart attempts at institutional capture. 

Hereditary institutions may actually grant greater amounts of freedom because the hereditary ruler is entirely dependent on maintaining the status quo as it is for his own power, and there is no access point for those who would befoul the liberty that is being enjoyed. 

The great irony is that the surest way to guarantee that a society remains free and does not enslave itself is perhaps a monarchy. 

Tuesday, October 27, 2020

Interpersonal Subjectivity

 There is an objective reality to the universe. 

Objectivity exists in two ways; First, there is an exclusive, single set of facts about what actually happened. We may not know it, but we know that only one reality unfolded. Were the north and south kingdoms of Egypt united through war, or through some diplomatic or otherwise peaceful means? We do not know, but we know that they were eventually united, and that some series of events precipitated their unity. 

Second, there is the truth of God, which functions as objectivity over topics that we would normally consider subjective. If God says that murder is wrong, it does not matter what twisted logic the murderer presents. It is as good as objectively true because the architect of all has declared it as such. 

This ultimately leads us to Interpersonal Subjectivity, which is the reality that most of us life in. 

We cannot force any sort of agreement about value-systems, morality, abstract principles which have to be followed.We have to have the same faith or principles in order to achieve this as there is no way to demonstrate this end. 

Perhaps even more poignantly, humans often cannot even agree on the facts. There are always conspiracies about whether data was covered up, manipulated, or not fully disclosed. There is also always the potential that the correlation of the events does not mean that there is necessarily the same cause behind them. 

All discussion in the world ends up actually functioning as interpersonally subjective even if objectively true things or moral things are being said. 

This functions as a sort of curse over human interaction. But it is also a blessing in the sense that it can also be the basis for liberty. 

Thursday, October 22, 2020

What Is Tradition?

 First, tradition, in the sense of it being an ideal,behaves the same way that any sort of high culture behaves. It is a series of ideas and reference points... thus, it is always an imagined, perfect thing, that does not reflect reality completely. Reality is always streaked through with human flaws.



Just like democracy or the idealized monarch, tradition is an ideal that people try to uphold. Of course, it is different from ideals in the sense that it is largely based on something handed down and much of it does not necessarily exist in a way that is ideological...

Tradition could be conceived of as the ideological prior to the popularization of the ideological. It can also be conceived of as a meta-ideology, or an ideology for everything, It is meant to encompass all wisdom, and to be the underpinning of some sort of civilization. Perhaps it can even be said that tradition is open to itself being manifested in a series of ideologies. 

Tradition is to ideology as perhaps civilization is to culture. For it is something that can spawn multiple cultures, and, in addition to spawning culture, it contributes to many other things. 

Of course, we can cut up the concept of tradition infinitely, just as we can cut up the category of culture infinitely, until each region, each age-group, each subdivision of art has a culture, and it is easy to digress infinitely on something like this, and even easier for someone to say that they do not share this lofty view of what constitutes tradition, but remember, we are using tradition here in a way that transcends any sort of normal use. 

Tradition is no longer just a word filling an expected linguistic role. 

In this context, it is part of an ideology, and a way of life. 

Tuesday, October 20, 2020

Hypocrisy & Jokes

 One of the main reasons religion tends to be despised is the perception of its hypocrisy. Hypocrisy is likely one of the main things that fuels contempt, and also is fodder for comedy.

I remember hearing that one of the main elements of comedy is surprise, and within the very concept of hypocrisy there is also surprise. This makes the whole edifice of stuffy, hypocritical religion a popular target for comedy. 

You can tell who really has the power in any given moment based on who you cannot joke about. It is not exactly a 1:1, as you are not necessarily going to be led exactly back to the authoritarian every time you determine what can't be joked about. Sometimes, it's Caesar's favorite pet or the charity that he set up. 

Comedy itself is a form of criticism. 

Perhaps it is the case that we must welcome even the most scathing comedy directed at ourselves because it is precisely what will humble ourselves. 

Monday, October 5, 2020

Everyone Pays for What they Have

I had an NCOIC in the Army that was a body-builder -- not just a guy who liked the gym a lot and had big muscles, but the guy who, in a group of strong, buff guys, would still be easily identifiable as THE body builder in the group. 


What stood out about him was the crazy amount of sacrifice that went into his body. He exercised twice a day, for two hours, and Saturdays and holidays always started off with a massive 4-6 hour gym session. He never drank, meticulously regulated everything he ate, and led the cleanest lifestyle of us all. Even though the guy probably had this natural talent all along, this was completely obfuscated by the amount of discipline & effort he put into it. 


You can see this with everything... 


Ever hear the weekly schedule of a chess grandmaster? I remember hearing the scheduel fo Levon Aronian and the guy studies chess 8 hours a day, 6 days a week, and he rests on Sunday with... 4-6 hours of chess.  And this is not playing chess -- he's not on some Live stream laughing it up while people donate him money. He's buried in books, being coached by elite chessmen, and playing exhausting, rigorous games against chess engines. 


I learned that people basically get what they put in. 


And that is fine.


It is a lot easier to not be jealous of a chess master when you realize that you spend 50 hours a week less than him studying chess; it's a lot easier to not be jealous of a supermodel when you realize that you get to eat pizza and don't live in a gym. It also develops a greater sense fo respect for their sacrifice and, to some extent, it makes them look a little bit silly and not right in the head. Not that this is necessarily true -- perhaps they really do enjoy it more than we enjoy our regular jobs, but imagine the horror of hearing about a model or chess player who turned his hobby into his job, and subsequently his hobby became his torture machine.

If Enlightenment Is Real, Christianity Is the True Religion.

  This is because enlightenment is non-universal, and its non-universality would imply that the Christian accounting of what an enlightened ...