Thursday, October 22, 2020

What Is Tradition?

 First, tradition, in the sense of it being an ideal,behaves the same way that any sort of high culture behaves. It is a series of ideas and reference points... thus, it is always an imagined, perfect thing, that does not reflect reality completely. Reality is always streaked through with human flaws.



Just like democracy or the idealized monarch, tradition is an ideal that people try to uphold. Of course, it is different from ideals in the sense that it is largely based on something handed down and much of it does not necessarily exist in a way that is ideological...

Tradition could be conceived of as the ideological prior to the popularization of the ideological. It can also be conceived of as a meta-ideology, or an ideology for everything, It is meant to encompass all wisdom, and to be the underpinning of some sort of civilization. Perhaps it can even be said that tradition is open to itself being manifested in a series of ideologies. 

Tradition is to ideology as perhaps civilization is to culture. For it is something that can spawn multiple cultures, and, in addition to spawning culture, it contributes to many other things. 

Of course, we can cut up the concept of tradition infinitely, just as we can cut up the category of culture infinitely, until each region, each age-group, each subdivision of art has a culture, and it is easy to digress infinitely on something like this, and even easier for someone to say that they do not share this lofty view of what constitutes tradition, but remember, we are using tradition here in a way that transcends any sort of normal use. 

Tradition is no longer just a word filling an expected linguistic role. 

In this context, it is part of an ideology, and a way of life. 

Tuesday, October 20, 2020

Hypocrisy & Jokes

 One of the main reasons religion tends to be despised is the perception of its hypocrisy. Hypocrisy is likely one of the main things that fuels contempt, and also is fodder for comedy.

I remember hearing that one of the main elements of comedy is surprise, and within the very concept of hypocrisy there is also surprise. This makes the whole edifice of stuffy, hypocritical religion a popular target for comedy. 

You can tell who really has the power in any given moment based on who you cannot joke about. It is not exactly a 1:1, as you are not necessarily going to be led exactly back to the authoritarian every time you determine what can't be joked about. Sometimes, it's Caesar's favorite pet or the charity that he set up. 

Comedy itself is a form of criticism. 

Perhaps it is the case that we must welcome even the most scathing comedy directed at ourselves because it is precisely what will humble ourselves. 

Monday, October 5, 2020

Everyone Pays for What they Have

I had an NCOIC in the Army that was a body-builder -- not just a guy who liked the gym a lot and had big muscles, but the guy who, in a group of strong, buff guys, would still be easily identifiable as THE body builder in the group. 


What stood out about him was the crazy amount of sacrifice that went into his body. He exercised twice a day, for two hours, and Saturdays and holidays always started off with a massive 4-6 hour gym session. He never drank, meticulously regulated everything he ate, and led the cleanest lifestyle of us all. Even though the guy probably had this natural talent all along, this was completely obfuscated by the amount of discipline & effort he put into it. 


You can see this with everything... 


Ever hear the weekly schedule of a chess grandmaster? I remember hearing the scheduel fo Levon Aronian and the guy studies chess 8 hours a day, 6 days a week, and he rests on Sunday with... 4-6 hours of chess.  And this is not playing chess -- he's not on some Live stream laughing it up while people donate him money. He's buried in books, being coached by elite chessmen, and playing exhausting, rigorous games against chess engines. 


I learned that people basically get what they put in. 


And that is fine.


It is a lot easier to not be jealous of a chess master when you realize that you spend 50 hours a week less than him studying chess; it's a lot easier to not be jealous of a supermodel when you realize that you get to eat pizza and don't live in a gym. It also develops a greater sense fo respect for their sacrifice and, to some extent, it makes them look a little bit silly and not right in the head. Not that this is necessarily true -- perhaps they really do enjoy it more than we enjoy our regular jobs, but imagine the horror of hearing about a model or chess player who turned his hobby into his job, and subsequently his hobby became his torture machine.

Wednesday, September 16, 2020

Has Christianity Become Less Literal?

There is a line of thought that Christian thought has become incredibly less literal as time goes on because literal interpretations are no longer tenable. We are forced to look at the Old Testament and other portions as being purely parable, not because we have always believed as such, but because it is now standing on untenable ground. 

But this really is not the case at all...

The Old Testament has been interpreted very liberally, with almost a sort of mysterious meaning, and the literal meaning has been treated as surface level. 

St. Maximus the Confessor is famous for looking at many Old Testament passages as parables, and you see this in other very early Christians. 

Here is St. Maximus the Confessor writing in the early 7th century:

"Intelligence and reason are to be treated like the bondservants of Hebrew stock who are set free at the end of six years (cf Deut. 15:12). They labor like a servant and a handmaid for everyone who practices the virtues, since they conceive and realize the qualities of active virtue, and their whole strength is as it were drawn up against the demons that oppose the practice of the virtues. When they have completed the stage of practical philosophy - and this completion is represented by the sixth year, for the number six signifies practical philosophy - intelligence and reason are set free to devote themselves to spiritual contemplation, that is to say, they contemplate the inner essences of created beings."

(In the Philokalia)

This quotation comes from the 5th century saint, St. Neilos the Ascetic: 

"Similarly, when a slave has come to love his master and his own wife and children, he may reject true freedom because of his bonds of physical kinship: and so he becomes a slave for ever, allowing his ear to be pierced through with an awl (cf Exod. 21:6). He will never hear the word that can set him free, but will remain perpetually a slave in his love for present things. This is why the Law commanded that a woman's hand should be cut off if she seized hold of the genitals of a man who was fighting with another (cf. Deut. 25:11); in other words, when there was a battle between her thoughts, whether to choose worldly or heavenly blessings, she failed to choose the heavenly and grasped those which are subject to generation and corruption - for by the genitals the Law signifies the things which belong to the realm of change."

(in The Philokalia)

St. Neilos the Ascetic
One of the more grave issues that we face is that this sort of misinformation about the Church fathers and what they thought, coupled with assumptions about historical thought in general, begins to create and foster atheism. It puts all of Christianity on a much weaker footing than it really is by trying to box it into bad theology. 

Because of a lack of familiarity with actual, true Christianity, due to poor, secular public education, the faith has suffered immensely, and we are failing in our duties to put God in His rightful place. 

Tuesday, September 15, 2020

Freedom & God's Plan (A response in Reddit)

 Recently, I saw a Reddit thread that somewhat caught my eye and decided to have a go at a response. 

In the initial post which concerned the problem of evil and how it is not resolved by justice in the afterlife, I saw the following quotation: 

This falls into Epicurus' malevolent description. God is able to stop evil but doesn't because justice will be served. If you could prevent a crime from happening, the moral decision would be to try and stop it not WAIT for it to be committed then exert justice. If you see a baby strapped to a chainsaw by a maniac, do you un-do the baby from the chain-saw or wait for the baby to be chopped up, then strap the maniac to the chain-saw? Evil on earth either matters or it doesn't. If it matters, then God is malevolent for allowing it but if it doesn't matter I could just go about on a murder spree since God will "make all things new" or "send my victims to heaven and torture me forever".

My response came largely inspired by the Church fathers: 

 The actual purpose of life is not to be enjoyed by being constantly shielded from injustice, but rather, the purpose is to morally grow and to actually deal with and digest all of our experiences.

To believe that we should always simply enjoy life and not grow from it reminds me of this quotation from Ilias the Presbyter:

"In addition to voluntary suffering, you must also accept that which comes against your will - I mean slander, material losses and sickness. For if you do not accept these but rebel against them, you are like someone who wants to eat his bread only with honey, never with salt. Such a man does not always have pleasure as his companion, but always has nausea as his neighbor." (in the Philokalia)

As St. Peter of Damascus says:

"Every trial and temptation is permitted by God as a cure for some sick person's soul. Indeed, such trials not only confer on us forgiveness of our past and present sins, but also act as a check on sins not yet committed." (in the Philokalia)

Life is to be viewed as a journey, ultimately, and thus even the evil things which befall not just us, but which befall others that we hear about, are to be considered as tools for us in our own spiritual journeys.

The man who loses a leg in a drunken motorcycle accident experiences excruciating pain, and then all sorts of subsequent emotional and mental pain from the loss of his leg. Yet, he has the power to make this a tool for change in his life to save himself from alcoholism and mortal sin.

Of course, that is not to say that we should view people who fail to transform themselves immediately after a great trial as somehow a moral failure... that is not our place to judge, or even to think about. Nor is this some callous way of justifying any evil thing that we ourselves do or indulge in...

But it is appropriate to understand the purpose of life not as some mere exercise in counting merits and demerits, but as one in which we are supposed to advance ourselves and our neighbors, taking advantage of both the good and bad times to learn our lessons and move forward.

Sunday, August 23, 2020

Bernie's Campaign Killed by Diversity?

The 2020s will likely be defined by the push for diversity among the Democrats and left wing parties throughout the Western world. Nothing will be considered good enough unless there is adequate representation of each group. The recent DNC convention shows as much: 

Top Latino activists and politicians are criticizing the lack of representation during this week's Democratic National Convention. 

Only three Latino speakers have their own speaking slot in the Democratic National Convention’s primetime lineup: Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-NY, New Mexico Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham and Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada.

 ,,,

 "I’d be lying to you if I said that I’m not disappointed that there aren't more Latinos and Latinas generally speaking on that program," Castro told MSNBC Saturday, adding that he's also disappointed that there isn't someone who is Native or Muslim American speaking during this primetime hour.

"You think about the beautiful coalition that has become the Democratic Party over the last few years, I'm not sure right now that it's fully represented on that stage," he added.

 USA Today

Ultimately, we can imagine that every single political campaign will see its diversity credentials brought into question. 

Indeed, it is potentially the case that some campaigns may even sabotage themselves by putting too much faith in diversity, as may be the case with the Sanders campaign. Some have put forth the theory that the bid of Bernie Sanders to win the nomination was ultimately destroyed by clamoring about making the staff more representative, which led to incompetent people being placed in key positions. 

Part of the explanation for this lies in the 2020 iteration of the Sanders campaign being predicated on multiple concessions to bad-faith critics. Immediately upon his official entry into the race last February, Sanders apologized for the 2016 campaign having been “too white and too male-oriented.” ... To make amends and preempt any future identity-related attacks, the 2020 campaign staff was heavily diversified. And at least in the case of South Carolina—in retrospect the most important primary state of the 2020 cycle—many of these personnel were hobbled by remarkable incompetence, while internal campaign criticism became impossible.

 Much of the day-to-day logistics of the Sanders South Carolina campaign were run de facto by Nina Turner, a talented orator and popular media surrogate, but someone whose skill set was clearly not suited to bolstering the image of a socialist from Vermont among southern black voters. For one thing, Turner’s political background was in metro Cleveland, which provides no necessary insight into best practices for winning over elderly, churchgoing black Democrats in the Deep South.

 In November 2019, Turner installed Jessica Bright as state director. Former staff members said Bright, who served as a Hillary Clinton delegate at the 2016 national convention, was hired in large part because her mother had filled the seat of Clementa Pinckney—the state senator killed in the 2015 Charleston church shooting. The idea was that such a transactional arrangement might compel the mother to endorse Sanders. “She couldn’t spell, she couldn’t speak coherently, and her mother ended up endorsing Biden,” one anguished former staffer recalled.2 Not only did basic tasks go unfulfilled, phone-banking and canvassing data were outright fabricated, multiple former staffers alleged, and sent to the national campaign headquarters to give the false impression of good progress being made in the state. “But you can’t say anything,” one staffer recounted thinking, “be­cause you’d be called a racist.” Communicating rationally with the twenty- and thirtysomething campaign staffers who dominated the South Carolina operation, this person said, was virtually impossible—almost like some kind of impenetrable generational and ideological divide had been erected. “I felt like I was in a daycare facility. These kids were just so clueless, and so full of themselves,” the person lamented. “It was a really dystopian feeling to work there, it was not like anything I’d ever been involved with.”3

American Affairs Journal 

Had Sanders received reliable data, he may have campaigned entirely different. Had there been a competent staff, the campaign may have made headway instead of rotting on the vine. 

While these sorts of what-ifs are impossible to resolve, it is certainly worth considering, especially as this problem looks like it will not be going away anytime soon. 

Tuesday, August 11, 2020

Colonialism & La Raza Cósmica

Res nullius, or terra nullius, was a doctrine that basically justified the colonization of massive parts of the world. Honestly, this is something that modern scholars have read back into the colonization efforts. Essentially, it deals with the justification for the taking of land from native populations. 

Basically, if a land is not effectively occupied, it is nobody's land. Some of the definitions try to make this more concrete by talking about societies that have not yet advanced to a position where they had not yet mixed their labor with the earth in any permanent way (Frost), but I think it may be more appropriate to emphasize the sparsity of population that usually described most of these places. The land was simply never occupied in truly significant ways, for one, and the obvious fact that when the English colonists took up position in Massachusetts Bay they could easily negotiate for settlement rights. 

The land could fit a lot more people than the 5,000 or so that were there, and, especially through technology and trade that the natives did not have, they would be able to radically change the region. We could say that the Europeans were able to apply a mix of res nullius and negotiated settlement: it was obvious that there was enough room for both parties, and it was also obvious that there would be advantages to mixing with the Europeans, so why not negotiate it? Why not be cooperative? 

From the perspective of the natives, the sacrifice of some amount of their hunting grounds for new potential allies that could give them trade and technological advances that would put them above their enemies. Moreover, the Wampanoag had just suffered a massive crisis of disease -- oddly enough, disease that may have had no connection to European colonization, and the disease even resulted in a spiritual crisis as their medicine men could not handle or explain it, and it led to many converting to Christianity early on (Wikipedia).

Obviously, conflict eventually occurred, and one can imagine that very similar stories unfolded in many other regions, where the initial settling was met with some amount of peace and acceptance, but it all boiled over, as it eventually boils over. 

I believe that when we think about the history of colonization in these terms, it is more understandable. Just as such, most sticking points in history can be tackled when we understand that the problem was less black & white. 

But because the interpretation of history can be weaponized for advancing a left or right position, we have to actually resolve it in a more final way. 

Cue la raza cósmica.

Perhaps the one thing that makes this a sticking point in North America is the lack of intermixing. The narrative among Latinos, as I understand it, is that they have become la raza cósmica -- the problem of colonization is resolved by bringing all Latino identity into a single racial construct. 

Are latinos white? Yes. 

Are they Indian? Yes.

Are they black? Yes. 

Can more recent immigrants from Asia and the Middle East have children & grandchildren grafted onto the Latino community? Well, that's the plan, isn't it? The Latin Americans are the cosmic race being unfurled by God: all peoples coming together into a post-racial existence. 

In a sense, the cosmic race is the post-race. 

While I am not sure if this is what was meant by Vasconcelos when he wrote about it in the 1920s, this is how I have understood it from interactions with a limited amount of Latinos that I know. The undestanding is far from scholarly, but just like in most cases, the folk understanding of an idea is often more important than the scholarly version. 

Jose Vasconcelos who coined the term 'cosmic race'

The Latin American world solved the problem of the legacy of colonialism through dissolution of racial identity and intermarriage. While there may still be some that think in terms of castizos & mestizos, and it may even be a theme that would one day reemerge, it is effective in making the sins of history be forgotten via the union of victim & offender into a single national identity. 

In a sense, it is the most elegant of all resolutions, for it renders conflict irrelevant by making the grief and guilty a little bit of everybody's, and its measuring becomes something irrelevant. It could even be said that the only reason that "native lands" is still relevant among Norte Americanos is because they have not dissolved their differences through intermarriage.

The racial heterogeneity of North Americans, and their obsession with diversity, may actually be what is holding them back from fixing the problem. Nobody can move forward because we are still in the game of counting grievances and using history to jockey for position. We are stuck in a narrative of diversity that is not helpful, instead of a narrative that resolves our identities into a single one. 

If Enlightenment Is Real, Christianity Is the True Religion.

  This is because enlightenment is non-universal, and its non-universality would imply that the Christian accounting of what an enlightened ...